Without initial ad. leaf. Text in two columns; a little spotted, title page sl. torn in inner margin where wrappers removed, without loss. Disbound. 31pp. Smith USA II, 3; the first impression. Smith notes, following detailed analysis of advertisements and notices in contemporary newspapers, that the Harper Brothers edition of A Christmas Carol was first offered for sale on January 24th 1844. This preceded by several months the Carey & Hart finely produced illustrated edition, which evidence suggests first appeared in April 1844. Thus, Smith concludes, (and in concordance with similar research conducted by Sumner & Stillman), 'until evidence to the contrary is uncovered, Harper's edition should be considered the first American edition.